What Is Borderline Personality Disorder, and How Can It Lead to a Breakup?
By Coach Craig Kenneth, with Coach Margaret
How can someone see you as wonderful one day and terrible the next? Why can a disagreement seem to erase everything good about your relationship?
In this conversation, Coach Margaret and I explored borderline personality disorder, relationships, and a pattern called splitting: seeing people as all good or all bad, with very little room in between.
Margaret drew on her experience in private practice, adolescent group care, and the prison system. The explanations and clinical perspectives below are hers, adapted from our original conversation. This is an archival discussion, rather than a diagnostic checklist or a comprehensive account of current clinical understanding.
1. Margaret’s Explanation of Early Emotional Hurt
Margaret believed the emotional hurt involved in the development of borderline personality disorder could begin very early in life. As she put it, this happens, “at least in my opinion, between the first and second year.”
She described the first year as a time when a baby experiences a caregiver primarily as someone who feeds, holds, comforts, and gives. As the child gets older, that same caregiver begins making demands, saying no, and setting limits.
In Margaret’s explanation, the difficulty begins with what the baby did not receive: enough holding, snuggling, attention, playful interaction, and stimulation.
She pointed out that there can be many reasons a caregiver struggles to provide those things. A mother may have postpartum depression, be overwhelmed by family problems or homelessness, or have several other children needing attention.
Margaret’s point was that a baby still needs that care, whatever the circumstances around the caregiver.
When the Same Caregiver Starts Saying No
Margaret explained that a securely attached child can become angry with a parent while still trusting that the parent loves them. In the developmental picture she described, a child who does not feel secure may be afraid to risk that anger.
The child cannot put the experience into words: Why don’t you love me the way you did before? Why are you telling me no?
Margaret also discussed children exposed to abuse or frightening circumstances, where upsetting a caregiver may feel dangerous.
She recalled knowing two people who had experienced digestive difficulties as infants and had been hungry for months before their problems were diagnosed. In her interpretation, those experiences could leave a baby feeling constantly uncomfortable and afraid of dying.
According to Margaret, the child in this situation may experience the comforting caregiver and the demanding caregiver as though they were two different people. This was how she explained the beginning of dividing people into good and bad.
2. What Is Splitting in Relationships?
Throughout our conversation, Margaret returned to one central idea: people are a mixture of qualities. Someone can disappoint you and still care about you. A person can set a limit and still love you.
In the pattern she described, holding those two realities together is difficult. Instead, someone is wonderful—or someone is awful.
Margaret used everyday examples to make this easier to understand. A person might insist that everyone at one store is terrible and that they will never shop there again. Meanwhile, everyone at another store is wonderful.
But stores, businesses, and people are rarely that simple. One employee may be helpful while another is having a bad day. An experience can be disappointing without making everyone involved a bad person.
Margaret explained that these judgments can also reverse. The person or business that was wonderful a few weeks ago can become the one that supposedly does everything wrong.
The Good Parent and the Bad Parent
Margaret gave the example of a child entering a foster home and dividing the parents into good and bad. Dad might be good and Mom bad. On another day, those roles might switch.
In her explanation, the struggle is seeing someone as a whole person who can offer both love and limits.
That same difficulty can show up in a romantic relationship. If a disagreement changes how your partner sees you entirely, working through an ordinary problem can become much more complicated.
3. Why a Disagreement Can Feel Like the End of the Relationship
One of Margaret’s most memorable examples came from her private practice.
She described a woman who would become annoyed with her and stop attending sessions. Months later, the woman would return and say she had assumed Margaret would no longer speak to her.
Margaret’s response was straightforward: Why wouldn’t she speak to someone she had known for years?
The woman would explain that they had argued during their last session. Margaret would remind her that people have disagreements, get over them, and continue their relationships.
For Margaret, that experience was therapeutic in itself. The disagreement had not erased the relationship. Anger had not made continued connection impossible.
She described the underlying dilemma as desperately wanting closeness while fearing that a problem with someone could mean never having a relationship with them again.
4. The Relationship Patterns Margaret Asked People to Notice
In the video, we discussed several patterns Margaret associated with borderline personality disorder. She also emphasized that people vary in how many difficulties they experience and how well they function.
Moving From One Intense Relationship to Another
One pattern we discussed was moving from one intense relationship to another, often with considerable drama and stress.
Margaret encouraged people to look more closely when a relationship seems to involve constant crises. The person calls repeatedly, everything feels urgent, and nothing seems to get resolved. One possible solution does not work, then another does not work, and the crisis continues.
Her point was to notice the ongoing pattern rather than looking only at one upsetting incident.
Feeling That Others Must Make Up for Earlier Unmet Needs
Margaret also discussed what she called entitlement. In her explanation, someone whose needs were not met early in life may feel that other people are now obligated to meet them.
She illustrated this with a former client who had a perfume allergy and traveled to appointments on a Medicaid bus. Margaret recalled that the woman believed the bus company should prohibit perfume on her bus.
Margaret saw that example as reflecting an expectation that the surrounding world should reorganize itself around the person’s needs.
“You Never Took Good Enough Care of Me”
Margaret described an underlying complaint she had encountered repeatedly:
“You never took good enough care of me.”
It might show up as anger that someone did not reply quickly enough, that a business made an error, or that a hotel failed to provide the expected care.
She also described conflicts with landlords, where the person responsible for the apartment becomes the focus of complaints about not being adequately cared for.
In Margaret’s view, the details could change while the central feeling remained the same: someone had failed to provide enough care.
When Giving More Still Does Not Satisfy
We discussed the example of someone saying their favorite ice cream is chocolate. You go out of your way to bring chocolate, only to be told that they love vanilla.
Margaret connected this to situations where someone makes an unreasonable demand and then remains dissatisfied even after another person goes to considerable trouble to meet it.
For the partner, this can be confusing. You listened, made the effort, and tried to give what was requested. Yet the effort still did not seem to count.
Margaret’s point was that meeting every demand does not necessarily resolve the underlying difficulty.
5. Childhood Trauma and an Alarm System That Stays On
Margaret discussed childhood sexual and physical abuse as experiences she had encountered in people with these difficulties. She described children feeling powerless, hurt, and traumatized.
To explain the ongoing internal distress, we talked about the body’s alarm system.
If a car almost hits you, you may feel a sudden surge of adrenaline. You are shaken, but eventually that response settles down.
Margaret described an experience in which the alarm stays on, and the person may not always know why they feel so distressed.
We also discussed self-injury. In Margaret’s explanation, physical pain may become a way someone tries to change an unbearable internal state or shift attention toward an injury.
She recalled adolescents in group care, and later people in the prison system, who hurt themselves in an effort to calm down enough to sleep. Her emphasis was on the severity of the turmoil they were trying to manage.
6. Why Kindness and Limits Need to Come From the Same Person
Margaret was particularly clear about one approach she did not find helpful: arranging for one person to be the good one while another person becomes the bad one.
She explained that a good-cop, bad-cop arrangement reinforces the very division she was trying to help the person move beyond.
Instead, she emphasized the value of someone who is kind and also sets limits.
“What’s helpful … is to see somebody being kind to them who also sets limits with them.”
In Margaret’s view, experiencing those things together can help someone feel safer and grow. The same person can care about you, tell you no, and remain in a relationship with you.
That brings us back to her example of the client returning after an argument. Margaret could disagree with her without rejecting her. The relationship could continue.
7. Margaret’s Discussion of Splitting and Dissociation
Toward the end of our conversation, I asked Margaret about splitting, dissociation, and experiences involving multiple identities.
She initially cautioned that this was a complicated topic that would deserve its own discussion.
Margaret described dissociation as a disruption in the usual experience of who you are, where you are, what you are doing, and what is happening around you. At the mild end, she used the familiar example of someone seeming to drift away mentally during a conversation.
For the more extreme experiences we discussed, Margaret offered a trauma-based explanation: the abuse can feel like more than one person can bear, and the mind finds ways to cope with that overwhelming experience.
When I asked whether everyone with borderline personality disorder dissociates in that way, she said no. She explained that these experiences could coexist, without saying that every person with BPD has multiple identities.
These were distinct topics within our conversation: splitting referred to the all-good or all-bad view of people, while dissociation concerned disruptions in a person’s experience of themselves or their surroundings.
8. Can These Relationship Difficulties Improve?
Margaret described personality disorders as long-term conditions that influence how someone sees the world and experiences relationships. She emphasized that change can be challenging and requires substantial work and motivation.
She also said:
“There isn’t much that can’t be corrected somewhat or made better or made conscious so you can at least handle it better.”
Margaret did not describe the process as easy. Talking about painful early experiences can bring difficult feelings to the surface. Nevertheless, she emphasized talking about those experiences as part of the work she believed could help.
For someone dating a person with these struggles, her advice was to take a long and careful look at the relationship and the patterns within it.
9. You Can Fall in Love With Someone Who Has Serious Difficulties
Margaret ended with a point that matters to anyone trying to make sense of a painful relationship: it is possible to fall in love with someone who has a severe personality disorder.
She noted that someone can be charming and appealing while also having serious difficulties. She recalled men she had encountered in the prison system who could be very pleasant within that setting and who themselves acknowledged that life outside was different.
Her advice was not to automatically write someone off. It was to look carefully.
The connection you feel is part of your experience. So are the crises, the disagreements, the changing judgments, and whether the person is willing to work on the difficulties affecting your relationship.
Margaret’s message throughout our conversation was that understanding these patterns matters—and that care and clear limits need to exist together.
If you would like personalized guidance about your breakup or relationship, you can learn about private coaching with Craig or Victoria, The Knowledge Workbooks, and the Creative Healing Course at AskCraig.net.